Good debate started here.
> Ah yes, but where? My understanding is that San Diego, Los Angeles and Las Vegas
> are all popular US destinations from Oz. While I personally would love to see the
> game played in KC (preferably in the suburbs in the southwest part of town), I'm
> thinking one of the above venues would be more likely to draw travelers from
> Australia.
> During the Olympics, the San Diego media liked to point out their similar climate to
> Sydney. That might be an argument for playing there.
> Would the weather in Las Vegas conducive to playing footy October through March?
I don't think drawing visitors from Australia should be the issue. We'll take their money and we'll welcome them but the focus must be on selling tickets to Americans and Canadians. After all, the whole point of having a match here should be to popularize the game with the present and future fans here. Ex-pats and visitors are a transient population. The biggest concentrations of footy fans in North America are in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Toronto, New York City, and Washington DC. Those are your candidate locations. Las Vegas and San Diego are in tier two based on AFANA's data.
> Some ideas
> - Following the season, and in conjunction with the US Nationals. Teams would
> already be planning to attend, so it would reduce the travel expense burden. It
> would also be an opportunity to promote US footy.
That's clearly one option. Exhibition games are principally a marketing exercise. The AFL doesn't do squat for fans here and this would be their chance. I believe that you are grossly underestimating where the interest in this match would come from. USfooty is one source but pales in comparison to the general fan base for the sport here (even now). We'd sell the clubs hard but we'd also want to target the general footy fan. Take 5,000 general footy fans and their families (and that would be 3% of the hard core US and Canadian fans) and you've made it profitable for the AFL.
- > Within a couple weeks of the New Year. This is when Australian schools are on
> their summer break, which could play into the Australians traveling to the US angle.
> But then you would almost need to be between Christmas and Jan 2, when American
> schools are on their winter break. And that would put you in competition with the
> college bowl games.
I think that early December to late January won't work for precisely the reasons you mention. Holidays and competing sports events. I'd never get my significant other to forego Christmas events to travel to a footy match. I doubt many other footy fans would be any more successful. Again, I really don't think the Australian school holidays are an issue.
- > I can't figure out how you would do it, but a tie in with the Super Bowl would be
> intriguing.
We'd get lost in the hoopla as some side show. Not to mention that hotel rooms in Super Bowl cities are double or triple the usual rates.
- > Bring a Wizards' Cup game to America. The advantage to this would be that it
> would be a game that (sort of) meant something.
AFANA has advocated this for years. Not sure the AFL is listening though.
- > Best possibility of all, and most unlikely of all, would be a regular season
> game. Perhaps at the bye week?
Based on previous conversations with the AFL, that won't happen until we establish exhibitions are big successes. Or you find some big financial underwriter and if we had that, the rest of this discussion would be renedered irrelevant.
> Can't really argue with you here. However, as you may have guessed, I think there
> is reason to promote the game in Australia also.
Well, we can but it shouldn't be the driving concern.
> I can think of two arguments here.
> - One is Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide or Brisbane. The advantage, from a
> promotional standpoint, is that these are cities that Americans have heard of.
But if all we are doing is promoting a footy holiday tour to America for Aussies, what's the point? Fans here should be the point. The future of the game here should be the object. If it isn't then the AFL doesn't need AFANA, USfooty or anyone else. They can schedule it whenever they want, hire an Aussie travel agent and reserve Disney World.
- > The other is Collingwood, Essendon, Richmond or Carlton. The advantage with the
> Big Four teams ties back to the idea of promoting the game as part of a trip to
> America.
However, from the standpoint of footy starved natives here, they could bring over Fremantle and Geelong and it would draw just as well. Sure, some fans here will say, as would an Aussie, if it ain't (fill in the blank) I won't go. But those fans are already lost causes and I won't worry about them. Remember, not one US or Canadian citizen has seen a footy match on US soil in 15 years. If that isn't a selling point, I don't know what is.
-Rob de Santos
AFANA Chairman
AFANA Blog