Skip to main content
Forums

Just watching the highlights show Crows v Swans

The SCG looks very small, the 50 meter line hits the center square.  Used to  watch one day cricket day night from the SCG and it never seemed that small.  Is there not any where in Sydney (Australia's largest city) some where more suited to AFL?  After the Olympics?  It looks embarising on TV to have such a weenie field!  Is there any AFL guidelines on how small a field can be?

Adelaide are the team to catch this year - but I don't see any match winners, like Judd, Brown, Ablott etc.  Are they just an all round good team?

The umps look terrible in green.  Why not go back to all white if the teams are mostly colours?

Setanta coverage rocks over anything we have had in recent history!  Thanks Rob and the AFANA crew.

May Barry Hall go down in history as the whiniest player in AFL history?

His forward mate O'laughlan is just awesome.

I would hate to be a Freo supporter with a weak heart.  My brother back in Perth loves them, but they them like an under-achieving bunch of potential stars.

Was that a dive in the world cup Aust v Italy?  That decision may have decided the whole world cup!

Lets get this discussion board going!

Bill W Buckin

 

 

 

Posted by surfworx on July 14, 2006

Thanks for your post Bill! I'll try answer a few of your questions........

Is there not any where in Sydney (Australia's largest city) some where more suited to AFL?  After the Olympics?There may be larger grounds in Sydney, but I'd say the SCG is the home of the Sydney Swans, and there are probably contractual reasons why games are played there. Annecdotally, it is a smaller playing surface.
Adelaide are the team to catch this year - but I don't see any match winners, like Judd, Brown, Ablott etc.  Are they just an all round good team?I think it is recognised that Adelaide a very much an all round good team, although Simon Goodwin does rack up consistently the most possessions, and in general the team's midfield and defence has been solid performers. They also tend to share the goal kicking around, rather than rely on one or two forwards.
Setanta coverage rocks over anything we have had in recent history!  Thanks Rob and the AFANA crew. Thank you for your fantastic feedback, and I'm sure the team take it on board.
May Barry Hall go down in history as the whiniest player in AFL history? Personally I think that might be a touch unfair, I know of the odd one or two former players now in the media like to make interesting comments about the game.
Was that a dive in the world cup Aust v Italy? Let's just say that this issue got alot of media attention in Australia.

Thanks again for making a contribution to the site. Great work!

Derrick

 

Posted by Bob on July 15, 2006

There is no standard size for footy fields, just as there is no standard size for American baseball fields.  Most stadiums are used for multiple sports (e.g. cricket), and building separate standard sized facilities in each AFL city would be mucho expensive.

The SGC at 149 X 118 meters is the smallest field in the league, and I believe it has been the home field of the Swans since they moved from South Melbourne (the 'Swan Man' would know this for sure).  Although the Swans usually play one or two games each season in Syndey's Telstra Stadium (160 X 118 meters), the SGC remains their home ground.

The 50 meter arc was only introduced at the SGC 2 or 3 years ago.  Before that the arc used to be 45 meters at the SGC.

I wish I could get Setanta.  I don't have Direct TV, so I have to listen to what I can over the AFL's Internet radio broadcasts.  Oh well, it's better than nothing.Image removed. 

Posted by KC Swan on August 17, 2006

The SGC at 149 X 118 meters is the smallest field in the league, and I believe it has been the home field of the Swans since they moved from South Melbourne (the 'Swan Man' would know this for sure).

Your facts are correct.  Until after the Olympics, the only Sydney venue for an official AFL game was the SCG.

The 50 meter arc was only introduced at the SGC 2 or 3 years ago.  Before that the arc used to be 45 meters at the SGC.

Actually, I believe the 50 has always been a 50.  The change was that it used to stop at the center square.

There was discussion on the old forum about what that small field meant to the Swans.  The common belief is that the Swans can never develop a proper CHF given the dimensions of the SCG.  Some have even suggested that this played a role in Kelly's short kick to Plugger in the '96 GF that swung momentum to the Kangaroos.

  -- Swannie
Posted by Bob on August 17, 2006

Actually, I believe the 50 has always been a 50.  The change was that it used to stop at the center square.

I seem to remember watching some games from the SCG a few years ago when the arc was 45 meters.  But since I can't prove it, I guess I'll have to accept Swan Man's version as the correct one.

I wonder Swannie, since you are a member of the Swans, any chance of verifying this with them?

 

Posted by KC Swan on August 20, 2006

Now that you push the point, it seems to me that maybe they did try a shorter arc one season to avoid cutting it off at the center square.  I had forgotten about that.

  -- Swannie
Posted by Bob on August 24, 2006

Now that you push the point, it seems to me that maybe they did try a shorter arc one season to avoid cutting it off at the center square.  I had forgotten about that.

I searched the Internet and couldn't find anything about the Swans using a 45 meter arc, so your info seems like a good compromise.  However, in my searching I discovered that the Australian Amateur Football Council uses a 45 meter arc.  (See section 7.4).

 

This is not meant to imply that the Swans are amateurs.  Image removed.  Unfortunately they lead both the Cats and the Blues again this year.  Image removed.

Recent content

Partners

Worldfootynews.com

ENJOY Three Months Free! 

VPN for Sports!

  • Need to access sports broadcasts that are blocked in your area? You need a VPN!
  • With ExpressVPN, you get a flexible VPN service that can be adjusted on the fly.
  • More than 105 countries supported.
  • The best part? Click on this offer and get 3 months FREE!
  • AFANA independently selects products we recommend through experience,
    and we may earn commissions on your order.

We Recommend:

ENJOY 40% OFF SITEWIDE!

  • The future of vitamins is here! Say goodbye to generic multivitamins cluttering your table top. 
  • With Vitable, you get personalized daily vitamin packs tailored to your unique diet, lifestyle and health needs.
  • All you need to do is complete a simple online quiz and unlock your expert recommendation. 
  • Join the 400,000+ people embracing the Vitable way with 40% OFF your first order
  • Use the promo code AFANA40 at checkout.
  • AFANA independently selects products we recommend through experience,
    and we may earn commissions on your order.